Urban Cinefile
"I did two period pieces so it was like, 'When are you going to get out of the corsets?' and I was thinking 'I just got into them!' "  -actress Frances O'Connor on her first international roles
 The World of Film in Australia - on the Internet Updated Tuesday September 15, 2020 

Printable page PRINTABLE PAGE



Set in 1870, this is the story of a volatile romantic triangle and the lives it consumes. Paul Verlaine (David Thewlis) loves genius teenage poet Rimbaud (Leonardo Di Caprio) because he finds him totally, powerfully exceptional. Rimbaud loves Verlaine because for a moment he thinks he has found the companion to share his search for the absolute. But Verlaine also loves his wife Mathilde (Romane Bohringer), who finds her husband magnetised by the intoxicating lure of Rimbaud, who illustrates the easy cruelty of young genius and the constantly warring creative and destructive forces that exist within the artist.

"The impeccable credentials of director and scriptwriter won’t rescue Total Eclipse, an interesting but tedious portrayal of two unlikeable historic characters, played by Leonardo Di Caprio and versatile UK actor David Thewlis. Di Caprio displays the boyish charm that has skyrocketed him to box office heart-throb status, but this despicable character, Rimbaud, is arrogant, uncouth and abounds with deplorable behaviour. Nonetheless, Di Caprio manages to exude charisma and gives a strong, brave performance. David Thewlis’ character, Verlaine, is so limp, weak, snivelling and pathetic, that it’s hard to believe Rimbaud can see anything at all of appeal, let alone be sexually attracted to him. Both actors attack their roles with enthusiasm, but the chemistry between the two is non-existent and their styles are very different. The manner in which Verlaine treats his poor wife Mathilde, is equally woeful, with lines like "I haven't set fire to her since Thursday." The script is ponderous with characters that are not fully rounded nor properly described and devoid of charm. There’s a lack of consistency too when it comes to the accents: Thewlis delivers an English accent, DiCaprio an American, Bohringer and others speak in English with a pronounced French accent. And it could be said that some of the colourful language belongs perhaps more readily to the 20th as opposed to the 19th century. A moody production with subdued colours and effective production design, Total Eclipse is a rather haunting glimpse into the bizarre mental anguish and behaviour of an artistic genius, and the destructive ensuing pattern of behaviour. The merits of the film, which is visually appealing and beautifully shot in picturesque locations, are unfortunately masked by its problems."
Louise Keller

"Once upon a time there was a renowned European director called Agnieszka Holland, who stunned movie audiences with such audacious works as Europa, Europa. Then Hollywood beckoned, and while she never went quite mainstream, her work thus far [with the possible exception of The Secret Garden] has been defined by a sense of the lacklustre, taking interesting period dramas and turning them into somewhat tiresome, uninteresting affairs [such as the upcoming Washington Square]. Why on earth a contemporary movie audience would be interested in the sexual goings on between youthful and wildly excessive poet Rimbaud, and the older intellectual Verlaine, is something of a mystery. The film's principal characters, as depicted here, lack any real depth or genuine humanity, making it difficult to maintain a reasonable emotional connection with either. As based on the Christopher Hampton play, the film adaptation is a stagy affair, dark and dimly lit, and overly verbose. Apart from the inclusion of a number of love scenes which may have DiCaprio's teen fans squirming in discomfort, the film's theatrical origins are, for the most part, in evidence. Di Caprio was once an interesting actor, but of late, he seems to walk through his roles with an air of righteous simplicity. He's the only American in the cast, and stands out like a sore thumb, clearly miscast and it seems, out of his depth. David Thewlis, however, makes up for his co-star's shortcomings. There's little energy in Holland's direction, and the film meanders along adding little insight into its central relationship. Ultimately, rather than suffer through this film better read the poetry of these two instead. It's far more profound."
Paul Fischer

Email this article


Favourable: 0
Unfavourable: 2
Mixed: 0


CAST: Leonardo di Caprio, David Thewlis, Romane Bohringer

DIRECTOR: Agnieszka Holland

PRODUCER: Jean-Pierre Ramsay Levi

SCRIPT: Christopher Hampton


EDITOR: Isabel Lorente

MUSIC: Jan A.P. Kaczmarek


RUNNING TIME: 120 minutes



© Urban Cinefile 1997 - 2020