Urban Cinefile
"I love my life the way it is now, the fact that I CAN go down the street with minimum make-up, and not have somebody stare at me"  -Actress, Charlize Theron
 The World of Film in Australia - on the Internet Updated Wednesday August 14, 2019 

Search SEARCH FOR A FORUM
Our Review Policy OUR REVIEW POLICY
Printable page PRINTABLE PAGE

Help/Contact

EDITORIAL- 2/5/2013: THE LESSONS OF SALEM

By Andrew L. Urban

By a fateful coincidence Thomas Vinterberg’s latest film, The Hunt, opens in Australia this week, two weeks before Vinterberg walks the red carpet at Cannes as the head of the jury for Un Certain Regard. (The Hunt was in Competition last year and its star, Mads Mikkelsen won the Best Actor Award.) The second relevance is that Australian audiences will be seeing The Hunt in the wake of news last week that Rolf Harris has been questioned by police in the UK as an extended part of the investigation into the paedophilia case against Jimmy Savile.

In case you don’t know, The Hunt is the story of Lucas (Mads Mikkelsen) a kindergarten teacher in a small Danish town. Now, following his divorce, made especially painful when his wife moves away with their teenage son, Marcus (Lasse Fogelstrom), Lucas' life is recovering, with a new girlfriend Nadja (Alexandra Rapaport), and the reforging of his relationship with Marcus. His world comes crashing down, however, when 5 year old Karla (Annika Wedderkopp) suggests to the headmistress Grethe (Susse Wold) that he has exposed himself to her. It's a simple lie that spirals out of control and the small community suddenly finds itself in a collective state of hysteria. Long held friendships are tested as hate and mistrust spreads.

The way Vinterberg shows how this comes to pass is masterful, credible, shattering cinema. By another fateful coincidence, Broken, by British filmmaker Rufus Norris, which opens here on May 16, tells the story of how not a 5 year old but a 15 year old girl wrongly accuses a young man in her heighbourhood of sexual misconduct, with tragic consequences for many lives around her.

"a mirror to society"

So not only are these films sharply relevant, they are also a reminder of the lessons we should have learnt from the 17th century witch hunts of Salem. Cinema can be more than entertainment; it can be a mirror to society.

Writing in The Australian last weekend, Frank Furedi picks up the topic in an article headed: “Savile inquiry shows that sometimes, there can be smoke without fire” (Frank Furedi's Moral Crusades in an Age of Mistrust: The Jimmy Savile Scandal is published by Palgrave Macmillan.)

He starts: “If there is any truth to the adage that there's no smoke without fire, a lot of people targeted by the police inquiry into historic crimes associated with Jimmy Savile are going to find their reputation has been torn to shreds.

“Rolf Harris is only the latest, and arguably most famous, celebrity to be caught up in a police investigation that appears to have acquired a life of its own. It is paralleled by a campaign of fear that relies on social media to casually target its victims.

“The destructive consequences of this moral crusade was all too apparent last November, when a network of British commentators wrongly accused Alistair McAlpine of being an abuser of young boys. Rumour-mongering acquired a powerful momentum as different zealots harnessed the anxiety fuelled by press speculation to promote their own agenda. Sadly, the spirit of an inquisitorial crusade also affects the way the police have gone about their investigation.”

In the context of that investigation, Operation Yewtree, the matters are historical allegations. “It is likely the main accomplishment of Operation Yewtree will be the destruction of reputations. No system of real justice can test the merits of a retrospective allegation made about an individual act of abuse committed more than 40 years ago.

“It can be used, however, to make an example and tarnish the name of the accused. The mere act of arresting someone on such a historical allegation is sufficient to call into question the moral status of the individual.”

"to avoid burning the innocent, mistaking them for ‘witches’"

But even current allegations need to be treated with care – especially in an age when instant global communication puts an immense responsibility on us to avoid burning the innocent, mistaking them for ‘witches’.

Furedi quotes Joshua Rozenberg, a respected British commentator on legal issues, who argues “society will have to learn to live with accepting that just because people are arrested and accused of a crime does not mean they are guilty. Rozenberg acknowledges there is a problem, which is that "innocent people are sometimes arrested". He argues that "it's for the public to understand that, sometimes, there can be smoke without fire".

And so it is in The Hunt: Lucas is the witch who comes face to face with 17th century responses to 21st century circumstances. It’s a lesson worth repeating, since we do not seem to have grasped it, even though we think we have.

Email this article


Salem Witch Trials


The Hunt







© Urban Cinefile 1997 - 2019