Urban Cinefile
"I never believed that life and farce are mutually exclusive - they're much the same in fact. "  -- P.J. Hogan, on his film Muriel's Wedding
 The World of Film in Australia - on the Internet Updated Saturday February 1, 2020 

Printable page PRINTABLE PAGE



In 1867, the town of Kingdom Come is run by one man – Daniel Dillon (Peter Mullan). He not only owns every building, but his mistress Lucia (Milla Jovovich) runs the saloon and bordello. Two events disrupt the ordered serenity of the town. The stagecoach brings Ellen Burn (Nastassja Kinski) and her daughter Hope (Sarah Polley) to town – ostensibly to visit a relative. Then from the wilderness, a group of men led by Dalgliesh (Wes Bentley) arrives. They’re a survey team from the railroad company, looking for a way through California’s Sierra Nevada mountains for the trans-continental railway. A station in Kingdom Come would change the town’s fortunes. And the two sets of visitors will change Dillon and Kingdom Come forever.

In popular culture, there are few mythologies as powerful as that of "the West". From Roy Rogers to Clint Eastwood, audiences have always loved the genre. Now Michael Winterbottom both redefines the Western and confirms its power as he transplants that very English story The Mayor of Casterbridge (by Thomas Hardy) to the California mountains. In common with many other Westerns, the authority figure (Dillon) is deeply flawed – in this case by something he did many years before. But unlike the archetypal Western, it’s not a gunslinger who rides into town to herald that change is in the wind; it’s two women and a surveyor. Winterbottom then sets about creating one of the most visually stunning and deeply involving films I’ve seen for quite a while. The Claim evolves at a very deliberate pace; which may infuriate some. But like much of Hardy’s dense writing, the tale needs time to develop. Amidst majestic snow-covered mountains, Winterbottom is provided with the perfect backdrop to stage some of the most spectacular scenes ever committed to film. He also captures a credible frontier spirit – showing us a time when conditions were harsh and the railroad (something we take for granted) literally meant the difference between life and death. The cast – a blend of younger actors and screen veterans – works tightly as an ensemble; with Wes Bentley and Sarah Polley both adding to their growing reputations. Nastassja Kinski is convincing as the fated Ellen and in Lucia, Milla Jovovich has finally chosen a role which allows her to display her talents without affectation. But Peter Mullan towers over this film. His brogue is tinted with the faintest American twang and he gives a tour-de-force performance as Dillon. The Claim has divided critics and audiences alike – a real love-it-or-hate-it proposition. But for its visual brilliance, tight and intelligent scripting, great acting and sheer intensity, I loved it.
David Edwards

The picturesque snowy village nestled beneath fir covered mountains effects such cinematic grace, that it is exquisitely beautiful to observe. And observe it we do for much of this leisurely told tale of the last frontier, allowing the physicality to give us a real sense of place. But life in the 1860s post gold rush is tough and we soon understand how difficult it is. Michael Winterbottom's saga from Thomas Hardy's book is both ambitious and risky. The very essence of the story relies heavily on understanding the way of life and the mindset of the characters. So getting the most out of The Claim requires considerable patience, as the morality tale unfolds slowly and surely over two hours. The script is intelligent, while the lensing of Alwin Kuchler is superb, showcasing the setting to perfection. The exterior shots show off the landscape, while interiors rely on very tight close ups – so intimate that the images are blurred. At times it is difficult to distinguish whose face or what body part fills the entirety of the screen. The contrast is as acute as the fire's heat and the chill of snow. Mark Tildesley's production design effects by its simplicity and Michael Nyman's themes pound relentlessly. Nyman's distinctive music is both effective and irritating. Its repetitive nature hammers claustrophobic dizziness, at the same time bringing a unique uniformity to this bleak environment. A strong cast, well directed, bring the characters to life: Peter Mullan's Daniel Dillon, a man wracked with guilt and regret; Wes Bentley's enigmatic Dalgliesh (it is extraordinary to realise that the charismatic star of American Beauty is only 22 years old); Milla Jovovich, her heart on display. Ironic that the three women (played by Jovovich, Polley and Kinski) are so totally different, yet each search for the same thing. Visually haunting, The Claim is engrossing cinema.
Louise Keller

Michael Winterbottom always gets the sense of place just right, projecting his audience into his cinematic world with great alacrity and detail. The Claim draws us instantly into the isolated frontier village of the late 19th century, but unlike most Western set movies, the climate is snowbound and the horizon grey. Not the people, though. Winterbottom has chosen a cast (not repeated previous castings) and as the old truism has it, that is 80% of the work done. Wes Bentley is terrific as a classic hero who is given some room to falter, and Peter Mullan is a solid counterweight as the man who has to confront his past and wear the pain; he welds the film’s drama to its humanity. Bentley here is often reminiscent of a young Clint Eastwood – without the Colt 45, but with that same clear eyed look that blends determination and deceny, with an edgy touch. The three central women are the emotional power source for the drama, though, and Milla Jovovich does her finest work here. All three are admirable, though, and there is never too much glamour in their presence – but then Winterbottom is English, after all. The redemptive theme is American (like the setting), while the style of the story is English (like the original novel) and the subject matter universal. It’s universal because it is the story that is triggered when a single, unique individual makes a life altering decision under duress. This is valid stuff, and worth the effort. Too long it might be, but it’s so darn well done.
Andrew L. Urban

Email this article

Favourable: 3
Unfavourable: 0
Mixed: 0




CAST: Wes Bentley, Milla Jovovich, Nastassja Kinski, Peter Mullan, Sarah Polley

PRODUCERS: Andrew Eaton

DIRECTOR: Michael Winterbottom

SCRIPT: Frank Cottrell Boyce (novel, Thomas Hardy)


EDITOR: Trevor Waite

MUSIC: Michael Nyman


RUNNING TIME: 121 minutes


AUSTRALIAN RELEASE: November 29, 2001 in Sydney & Melbourne; other states to follow.


© Urban Cinefile 1997 - 2020